Show Book List  | More books by Philip Pullman

Reviews from Amazon
Amazon.com (0440238145) 641 reviews
Amazon.com (0590112899) 641 reviews
Amazon.co.uk (0590112899) 177 reviews
Amazon.co.uk (0440238145) 177 reviews
Amazon.ca (0440238145) 531 reviews
Amazon.ca (0590112899) 531 reviews
A selection of these reviews is given below

Reviews elsewhere on the web:
InfinityPlus
sfreviews.net
Daniel P. Moloney
Epiphyte Book Review
kidsreads.com
complete-review.com

Philip Pullman

The Subtle Knife

The Subtle Knife is the second book in Philip Pullman's His Dark Materials trilogy. In this book Lyra crosses into another world, and meets Will a boy from yet another world - our own. One thing to note is that this book needs to be read as part of the trilogy. The first book (The Golden Compass) can just about be read on its own - although there are a few loose ends - but I would advise that to read the second book you need to have read the first and go on to read the third.

This book seemed to me to have a more sci-fi feel to it than the first, with Will and Lyra moving about between different worlds, and the possibility of interacting with the mysterious 'Dust' via scientific equipment. My feeling is that the books aren't really suited to the 12 year old readership which would be suggested by the age of Will and Lyra, but to a somewhat older readership. If you fit in to this category, but felt that the first book was too unsophisticated for you then you should still give the second a try, as you might find the sci-fi approach more to your taste.

Amazon.com info
Mass Market Paperback 304 pages  
ISBN: 0440238145
Salesrank: 18372
Weight:0.35 lbs
Published: 2003 Laurel Leaf
Amazon price $7.50
Marketplace:New from $2.35:Used from $0.01
Buy from Amazon.com
Amazon.co.uk info
Paperback 352 pages  
ISBN: 0590112899
Salesrank: 15987
Weight:0.53 lbs
Published: 1998 Scholastic Point
Marketplace:New from £2.70:Used from £0.01
Buy from Amazon.co.uk
Amazon.ca info
Mass Market Paperback 304 pages  
ISBN: 0440238145
Salesrank: 63266
Weight:0.35 lbs
Published: 2003 Laurel Leaf
Amazon price CDN$ 9.99
Marketplace:New from CDN$ 2.67:Used from CDN$ 0.01
Buy from Amazon.ca

Product Description
Lyra finds herself in a shimmering, haunted underworld—Cittàgazze, where soul-eating Specters stalk the streets and wingbeats of distant angels sound against the sky. But she is not without allies: 12-year-old Will Parry, fleeing for his life after taking another’s, has also stumbled into this strange new realm.

On a perilous journey from world to world, Lyra and Will discover an object of devastating power. And with every step, they move closer to an even greater threat—and the shattering truth of their own destiny.
 
Darker & scarier. Its a great book! *****
The Subtle Knife starts out with Will Parry and his mother. There are men looking for his missing father, and making his mothers mental health fail misserbly. He hides his mother and sets off to try and find his father. Will crosses into another world during his quest. A world of children. There are evil creatures called Specters that feed on adults (sort of in the way vampires do only they take their feelings). Will meets Lyra in this world and they help each other in their journeys. This book has a lot more death in it. It has some very sad and scary parts. I am really excited to read the third book. I cant wait to see what happens to Will, Lyra, Lyra's horrible mother (I sure hope she gets whats coming to her!) and everyone else.
 
His Dark Materials, Book 2: the subtle knife *
I order this audiobook over a month ago and i still havent recieved it yet. So be careful what u order on amazon.
 
Fantastically creative, profoundly heretical, thought-provoking ****
I read the second and third books of Philip Pullman's His Dark Materials trilogy back to back, so I don't think I can really comment separately on The Subtle Knife and The Amber Spyglass. I realy enjoyed the first book, The Golden Compass, finding it very creative and an exciting adventure. Finishing the trilogy, I realize that I didn't know the half of his creativity. The adventure kept on moving, keeping me gripped to the end, but the ideas he explores are bold and provocative. What happens when we die? Do we have souls? Does God exist, and is He good? I'd heard that these books were considered heretical by some, by I didn't realize the extent of it. From the point of view of organized Christianity, these books are profoundly heretical, far more so than the Da Vinci Code or Angels and Demons, even more than Satanic Verses is heretical for Muslims. The organized church in his book is a corrupt puritanical and power-hungry organization, with names like the Magisterium, the Consistory Court, and the Oblation Board making it a thinly veiled analogy of the Catholic Church. (The fictional church is based in Geneva, so it has Swiss Guards. Just how thin can the veil be?) His account of God, angels, and creation is revealed in the second and third books, and it is shocking. But what is most heretical is that he describes a world in which good and evil exist and people can be moral without needing a creator or an afterlife. Heaven is where we build it. All of this theology (or is it anti-theology?) is not dry philosophical prose, but is integrally woven into a fascinating fantasy of parallel worlds, intriguing characters, and a great battle between good and evil (though it's not always clear who is on which side until the end). One of the parallel worlds encountered is a very creative imagining of an alternate evolution. This trilogy is written as a fantasy for a youth audience, but like the latter Harry Potter books, deals with some dark themes that require a bit of maturity to appreciate. Unlike Harry Potter, where each of those books ended in a safe place, each of these books before the last one ends with things looking rather bleak. (In Hollywood's version of The Golden Compass, they had to twist the order of events to end on a more upbeat note.) But in the end, they really make you think about goodness and truth and self-sacrifice, and the meaning of life. I thoroughly enjoyed these books, but they are not for the theologically faint of heart.
 
Solid Sequel ****
This one picked up right away and was very interesting. I enjoyed it quite a bit. Mostly, I was thrilled and shocked with the end. It was exciting and surprisingly sad. I am very interested to keep reading. The religious stuff was a bit more involved in this one, and my only real complaint about the whole book was the over-use of the title within the prose.
 
the best book in the Trilogy.............and probably one of the best children's book i have ever read........ *****
as far as i can remember this book took me 2 to 3 days to finish...and tht was along time ago and thts a HUGE thing.........
this book was even more gripping than the previous one with more Mysterious BEings and all the parallel worlds..........
this kept me hooked till the very end.............
PHILLIP PULLMAN has written probably the most IMAGINATIVE book ever which doesnot follow any OBVIOUS storyline...........
its unpredictable and its ever so Un-understandable characters are worth to be discussed.............
 
the subtle knife *****
I was very pleased with this, it arrived when expected and was in perfect condition and safely packaged. I have no complaints
 
Subtle Knife doesn't quite cut the mustard ***
The subtle knife of the title represents the height of philosophical and technological achievement for the once great city-state of Cittàgazze. More powerful than a traditional magic sword, The Knife is the ultimate weapon - one that can split open the smallest particles of matter. In Pullman's alternative universes, it becomes a new Excalibur that, in the hand of Lyra's new friend Will, has the power to kill God.

This is an altogether more uneven work than "Northern Lights". Whereas the earlier volume was like a collage of elements from all the fantasies and legends that you'd ever read, this has an irritatingly fragmented, channel-hopping quality. There is a narrative to do with Dust, temptation and Original Sin, but this just pops up occasionally, as if the author suddenly remembers that this is what he's supposed to be writing about.

As before, good and evil come in a range of guises. There are good and bad witches, of course, as well as the fabulously evil Mrs Coulter. Then there are the unmistakably bad Muscovite troops (shades of the Cold War) and angels who are on the side of, well, the angels (whichever side that is). The cast of evil scientists is supplemented by a token good scientist in the shape of physicist and ex-nun Molly Malone who is the source of one of the few moments of humour when she wires herself up to a computer to indulge in something that is a cross between a séance and the Turing Test.

One of the fundamental tenets of the trilogy is that children are naturally good. This seems to be dramatically undermined when the main child characters, Lyra and Will, are set upon by a crowd of feral children (complete with rifles) in a scene less reminiscent of the rival gangs of Lyra's Oxford than the dark malevolence of "Lord of the Flies".

It remains to be seen whether, in the, the final part of "His Dark Materials" Will succeeds in his mission to kill God and whether, in doing so he becomes the saviour of the multiverse or, like an earlier particle splitter, he becomes "Death, the shatterer of Worlds"*.


*(Quoted from the Bhagavad Gitã by Robert Oppenheimer on seeing the first atomic explosion)
 
Better than Northern Lights *****
I really enjoyed Northern lights and couldn't see how Pullman would be able to make the sequel much better, but I'm glad to say he did. I thought The Subtle Knife was far better.

Unlike some reviewers I really enjoyed the fact that the novel focuses on Will, and other characters, rather than just solely Lyra. Although I like Lyra I don't think she's enough of a character to hold a whole series on her own so I really enjoyed this aspect of it.

One of the things that irritated me slightly in Northern Lights was Lyra's ability to solve everything immediately and not to get anything wrong. This is somewhat rectified in The Subtle Knife where both Will and Lyra make mistakes, making them far more rounded, and less irritating characters I thought!

I loved the idea of being able to enter and leave other worlds and I can't wait to read The Amber Spyglass to see how Pullman develops this idea further. The idea that characters in one world can be different characters in another was also intriguing, and adds to the level of unsureness (is that a word?) that is throughout the series.

I'd recommend this series to teenagers and maybe more mature, but younger, children- although start with Northern Lights first as otherwise you'll be totally confused!
 
What happened? *
I really enjoyed the first book, but the second is really bad. The introduction of Will takes the attention away from Lyra, a great central character. Put simply, good characters are wasted, a plot is hard to find, and all the good will built up in the first is betrayed in this novel. Which in fact is nothing more than an extended prologue for the third book.
 
Read The Golden Compass first! *****
These books are excellent stories, that stand up just as well as reading for adults as they do for teenagers. To get the full benefit, however, I seriously recommend that the trilogy is read in sequence.
 
Good Job *****
I placed this oder as a birthday gift to my daughter, It took awhile, but it got rectified> Amazon responded to my email very quickly. I ended up with 2 books. So I instructed them to go ahead and charge me for the other book. Very good service and wouldn't have it any other way. My daughter is very happy.
 
At times it felt like the TV show, Lost *****
I read "The Subtle Knife" soon after having seen the movie "The Golden Compass" and I couldn't have realized that the story in "The Golden Compass" was just the tip of the iceberg. "The Subtle Knife" is supposed to be teen fiction, but I found it to be one of the heaviest books I've ever read. And thus, I'll be waiting a bit to read "The Amber Spyglass", but I will be reading it. "The Subtle Knife" and Philip Pullman have made that mandatory.
 
Much more focused and exciting than the first ****
If you're thinking to read this series, His Dark Materials, or were a bit put off by the first book, don't hesitate in starting the second, The Subtle Knife. This one is significantly more focused and interesting than The Golden Compass.

I am thoroughly looking forward to finishing the series off now with The Amber Spyglass.
 
Lyra, new adventures, another mission and more friends... ****
"The subtle knife" is the second book in Phillip Pullman's "His Dark Materials" triology. The first book in the series is "The golden compass". If you haven't read it, don't continue reading this review because it has some spoilers. In case you have read "The golden compass", and are understandably eager to know how the story continues, I will give you some hints.

Do you remember the way in which "The golden compass" ended? Lyra and her daemon, Pan, enter an alternate world, passing through a bridge between worlds created by Lord Asriel. New adventures and an entirely new mission await them, as well as another friend, Will. Will Parry is a young boy from our world who is searching for his lost father, and running from the police after commiting a murder. Strangely enough, the fact that Will is a murderer makes Lyra trust him: after all, her dear friend Iorek is a murderer too.

Will and Lyra meet each other for the first time in a strange world where there are no adults, due to invisible Specters that kill them. That is the place where Will is going to find the Subtle Knife, a knife that can cut windows to other worlds, and that is capable of killing anything. Of course, that new tool will be highly useful to the children in their quest, related to the hideous crime Lord Asriel committed in order to create a bridge between worlds. Lyra and Will are not going to be alone, though: old and new friends will rush to help them. Unfortunately, they will also have to face old foes, and try to find out what some ambivalent people want from them.

On the whole, I think that "The subtle knife" is an entertaining book that will please those that have already read the first book in the series. Notwhitstanding that, I don't believe it is quite up to the very high standards previously set by "The golden compass". All the same, I recommend it as good reading material that you are likely to enjoy.

Belen Alcat
 
Even more riveting! *****
Once again Philip Pullman pulls off a spectacular work of fiction. The second book in His Dark Materials series is a must read for anyone who enjoyed the first book. I definately think the series should be read in order so that full understanding of the plot can be accomplished. Pullman succeeds in his creation of new and unique ideas for the second book.

Tachyos.org  |  Chronon Critical Points  |  Recent Science Book Reviews