Show Book List  | More books by Philip Pullman

Reviews from Amazon
Amazon.com (0440238137) 1484 reviews
Amazon.com (0590660543) 1484 reviews
Amazon.co.uk (0590660543) 758 reviews
Amazon.co.uk (0440238137) 758 reviews
Amazon.ca (0440238137) 1090 reviews
Amazon.ca (0590660543) 1090 reviews
A selection of these reviews is given below

 

Philip Pullman

The Golden Compass

'The Golden Compass' (or 'Northern Lights' as the version I read was titled) is the first book of Philip Pullman's 'His Dark Materials' trilogy. It's the story of Lyra Belacqua, who spends most of her time playing around the Oxford college where she lives. But her playmates are being kidnapped, and her decision to rescue them draws her into much wider conflicts. Pullman shows such inventiveness in creating a new world for his story that it's sometimes hard to put the book down. But Pullman's books haven't had the same kind of bestselling success as some other books of a similar genre. I think part of the reason for this is that Pullman isn't really sure who he is writing for.

Lyra is around twelve years old, and the action in the book suggests that this is sort of age it is aimed at. But Pullman seems to have a negative take on a lot of things - religion, science, parenting, and I think this would make me wary of giving it as a gift to someone of that age. There's also a lot of nostalgia for a bygone age, implying an older audience. I think if I had read it when I was twelve then I would have found it very confusing. But if you are an older reader who has realised that some children's books don't seem so childish after all then you should give Pullman's work a try.

Amazon.com info
Mass Market Paperback 368 pages  
ISBN: 0440238137
Salesrank: 306763
Weight:0.35 lbs
Published: 2003 Laurel Leaf
Amazon price $7.50
Marketplace:New from $0.64:Used from $0.01
Buy from Amazon.com
Amazon.co.uk info
Paperback 416 pages  
ISBN: 0590660543
Salesrank: 31680
Weight:0.66 lbs
Published: 1998 Scholastic Point
Marketplace:New from £3.99:Used from £0.01
Buy from Amazon.co.uk
Amazon.ca info
Mass Market Paperback 368 pages  
ISBN: 0440238137
Salesrank: 48774
Weight:0.35 lbs
Published: 2003 Laurel Leaf
Amazon price CDN$ 9.99
Marketplace:New from CDN$ 2.33:Used from CDN$ 0.01
Buy from Amazon.ca






Product Description
Lyra Belaqua is content to run wild among the scholars of Jordan College, with her daemon familiar Pantalaimon always by her side. But the arrival of her fearsome uncle, Lord Asriel, draws her to the heart of a terrible struggle—a struggle born of Gobblers and stolen children, witch clans and armored bears. And as she hurtles toward danger in the cold, far North, young Lyra never suspects the shocking truth: She alone is destined to win, or to lose, this more-than-mortal battle.
 
Excellent start to a great series. *****
A very good book that starts out a fabulous series. Well written and original, filled with believable characters in fantastic situations. Some of you may have heard the outrage from Christians or other religious groups about this series being anti-god, and there are some ways you could make the case that this is an athiestic series, but I found that it was ultimately about the complex beauty of the universe and the inherent divinity of the human soul.
 
One of the greatest, smartest fantasy novels that I've ever read *****
Wow! I just finished reading this for the first time, completing it only a few minutes before midnight and the beginning of 2010. I have to confess that I only recently learned about the series, but I instantly was interested in it after hearing about the premise. I was hooked immediately and read the entire book in less than twenty-four hours. I'm going to say very little since with 1,500 reviews no much remains to be said. I'll merely add that the book reminds me a lot of Keith Roberts's PAVANE and Alan Moore's THE LEAGUE OF EXTRAORDINARY GENTLEMEN, with perhaps a little bit of LORD OF THE RINGS thrown in (mainly Frodo's quest, which is similar to Lyra's). Everything in this book clicked for me. I loved the daemons, the armored bears, the assumption of millions of parallel worlds, the witches, the Gobblers, the Gyptians, and all of the major characters. I've already started THE SUBTLE KNIFE and it will unquestionably be the first book that I finish in 2010.

I would just ignore those giving this book low ratings (and there aren't many). They are aberrations. I can't imagine many literate individuals who won't be absolutely blown away by this. Not just fans of fantasy and SF, but people who love wildly imaginative works of fiction. Some Christians (and for the record, I'm an orthodox Christian, a former Southern Baptist [I left the convention after it became more and more progressively stupid -- the proclamation that wives were to be subservient to their husbands passed on the annual convention few years ago along with the incessant unbiblical idiocies of Richard Land made me give up and the SBC and become an independent Baptist instead) are bothered by the anticlerical tone of the book. But frankly, I am just not bothered by that. If one's faith is so fragile that reading a book that doesn't like Christianity can threaten it, one doesn't have much of a faith to begin with.

I don't know where this will rate among the best fantasy that I have read since I have all of one book and most of a second to go, but based on what I've read so far, I would have no trouble putting this up with C. S. Lewis's NARNIA, Tolkien's LOTR, and Rowling's Harry Potter books as the best fantasy that I have ever read.
 
What's the hype about? *
People aren't going to like me for not liking this series, but though I normally really love big thick books, this trilogy has more problems than I can list here, the main one being how boring it is, first one is 0k, second one takes forever and a lot of the plot points don't make a great deal of sense when you think about it, why is she explicitly attracted to murderers, for example (that's a little creepy to be honest).

First book is 0k action-wise, but highly prejudiced and ever-ready to caricature, the second and third are the same, but overlong, very slow, and very boring with little in the way of good action, to the point that I barely finished them, I'm not sure what the hype is about really, controversy couldn't make Dan Brown a good author, but he's still better than Pullman, who seems to hate rather a lot of people in a way I can only describe as xenophobic.

Mild Spoilers:

In the second book her original friend, who she travelled half way round the world for, is discarded, with hardly a thought, for her new, and more-or-less identical, companion (I noticed that an awful lot of the characters feel copy-pasted, most of the white bears are paper-thin and all the antagonists seem to run on bile with no real convincing motive or personality).

The final battle, as well as all the action, feels distant and rather mellow-dramatic, as did everything in the second book. The trilogy doesn't seem to end as much as peter out, I left this series feeling unsatisfied and slightly puzzled, to be honest I've put it in a box upstairs and will probably forget about it totally. The characters and plot were unmemorable, nobody really seemed motivated to do anything, but did it anyway (Which is roughly how I felt when I finished the book).

Overall, this averages out as one of the most boring trilogies I have read.
 
Complex and interesting *****
This book was excellent. Much better than I expected. I started reading it because I just had to see what the fuss was about. Actually I couldn't see the problem with this book at all. I didn't really classify it as a children's book after reading it, but only because I thought it was at a much higher reading level than other similar books such as Harry Potter or The Chronicles of Narnia. I thought the story was excellent, complex and interesting and the characters were extremely 3 dimensional. The movie was a wash out in comparison to the book.
 
The author blew it! **
This is a 3 book series of some fantastically written fiction about life in made-up, intermingling worlds different than our own, but with many similarities. The first book of the trilogy, Northern lights, was so good I got the second book as soon as I finished it. The second book, The Subtle Knife, hinted at the books main plot and because it was a very twisted view of some very real beliefs I was hoping the author was going to redeem himself by the end of the 3rd book and not continue in what he seemed to be implying. He could have, he's a brillant writer, but he didn't. 30 pages into the 3rd book, The Amber Spyglass, and I was ready to put the book down. It was rather disappoining that he was going down the road he was, but I was too curious, I really had enjoyed it up until this point. I still hoped he could make it all right by the end, though it seemed improbable. Maybe I was just fooling myself trying to justify why I was still reading it. Whatever the reason, I continued reading. However, because the thrill was gone the book became laborious to read, too many violent killings happening too many times; too many detailed descriptions of too many scenes. Still I finished it and the ending was sweet. BUT, the end doesn't justify the means, the author had an agenda and I felt like it was a sneaky, underhanded way of imposing it on his readers, or at least, this reader. That part was not fiction, it was quite clear that the author hates the church in general and God specifically. He made evil good and God a liar and humanism, no matter what you have to do to achieve it, the most important. Of course, if you don't believe in God, if you don't love him, it doesn't matter, enjoy the book. I'm one who loves the Lord and Pullmans agenda ruined the whole series.
 
Good, but not quite... ****
Well, where do I begin?

Without delving into the plot, I would like to make a few observations:

In essence the story is interesting and it held my concentration. There are a number of twists and turns and to Phillip Pullmans credit the story is entertaining. Each chapter unearths a new discovery, which contradicts what the reader had previously thought about the characters and plots. Although a `childlike' read, it was enjoyable.

However, I felt the alternative world created by Pullman could have been described more; it lacked sufficient detail for me and there was significant potential to paint a truly amazing world a reader could really be lost in. I also felt some of the characters were a little sketchy and not developed enough for me to believe them. Morevover, many of the characters and much of the plot succumbed to the same old clichés you find in other fantasy novels, prophecy, people coming together for the common good, long journey to be made to save the world blah blah blah...

An entertaining read but don't expect to be dazzled by description and unique characters.

Also for the record, I have given the book the benefit of the doubt with 4 stars although it really deserves 3½.
 
Ineffable *****
I can't describe the envy I have for people who are just beginning to read this book and have the experience still to come.
 
UTTERLY AMAZING *****
I've just finished reading this book and unlike some books i've read every chapter was fascinating and exciting and there wasen't any boring bits. I truly loved reading this and highly recommend it to anyone.
 
Better than Potter? *****
This is the first book of the His Dark Materials trilogy, touted my many as being a superior rival to the Harry Potter books. It's been on my "to-read" list for years and having been given it for my birthday I thought it was about time to actually read it. I can't believe I waited so long.

Set in a parallel universe, the plot centres on Lyra, a child who is cared for by staff at a college in Oxford. After overhearing a lecture by her Uncle, and a series of mysterious kidnappings, Lyra gets sucked into an adventure to find a missing servant boy.

The novel is populated with well drawn characters - the staid scholars of the college, the mysterious Mrs Coulter, the colourful Gyptions and a mighty armoured bear. The universe is familiar yet subtlety different with the exception of daemons; all the human characters are accompanied by an animal form (the daemon) - separate but interdependent - linked with an invisible bond.

Aside from the excellent writing - Mr Pullman scores several points over Ms Rowling in that regard - the novel is a gripping yarn. Not afraid to deal with violence and death, the story builds to a climax which simultaneously creates a bridge to the second novel. Indeed, Pullman expertly interweaves the story arc of this novel with the beginnings of the arc for the trilogy as whole.

Although nominally a Children's novel, it deals with big themes of identity, institutional (e.g. state or religious) control and philosophy. While I had some quibbles on elements of the ending, these do not distract much from my enjoyment of the story or the novel as a whole.

Is it better than Potter? While the writing is better, and the overall story arc more explicit from the outset, I wouldn't want to make a call in that regard. It's significantly different and more involved. Where Potter is escapism with dark themes throughout, this book is more about the ideas and themes themselves. You can still escape to Lyra's Oxford, though, and I recommend you do.
 
Rather boring *
People aren't going to like me for not liking this series, but though I normally really love big thick books, this trilogy has more problems than I can list here, the main one being how boring it is, first one is 0k, second one takes forever and a lot of the plot points don't make a great deal of sense when you think about it, why is she explicitly attracted to murderers, for example (that's a little creepy to be honest).

First book is 0k action-wise, but highly prejudiced and ever-ready to caricature, the second and third are the same, but overlong, very slow, and very boring with little in the way of good action, to the point that I barely finished them, I'm not sure what the hype is about really, controversy couldn't make Dan Brown a good author, but he's still better than Pullman, who seems to hate rather a lot of people in a way I can only describe as xenophobic.

Mild Spoilers:

In the second book her original friend, who she travelled half way round the world for, is discarded with hardly a thought for her new, and more-or-less identical, companion (I noticed that an awful lot of the characters feel copy-pasted, most of the white bears are paper-thin and all the antagonists seem to run on bile with no real convincing motive or personality).

The final battle, as well as all the action, feels distant and rather mellow-dramatic, as did everything in the second book. The trilogy doesn't seem to end as much as peter out, I left this series feeling unsatisfied and slightly puzzled, to be honest I've put it in a box upstairs and will probably forget about it totally. The characters and plot were unmemorable, nobody really seemed motivated to do anything, but did it anyway (Which is roughly how I felt when I finished the book).

 
Not Impressed ***
Lower class children are disappearing and when Lyra finds that her friend is missing she wants to find him and get him back. Lyra becomes caught up in her new life but eventually realizes that all is not as it seems and those she trusts are involved with the disappearance of the children. Lyra goes on a quest which ultimately results in her following her destiny. I wanted to like this book much more than I did. Honestly, I wasn't even close to blown away. The story was slow to start. Lyra was the only fleshed-out main character and I wasn't fond of her at all. Boring is the word that comes to mind. The book also ends with a cliff-hanger which is a technique I really do not appreciate.

I'm not saying this was a bad book though. Once the the pace picked up, I did find the story interesting and parts did read quickly. I'm finding it difficult to write this review as nothing really stood out to me as being great. It was ok; but I doubt I'll read the other books.
 
what's to rave about? ***
There are many people who liked this book, but I for one am not that impressed. I'm not saying it's horrible because it's not. It's a good read with an interesting concept, but compared to so many great children's literature out there, it's really not well written. Lyra isn't very likable as a character and Pullman's fantasy world is not very original let alone captivating.
I admit I didn't read this book by choice (it was for my Chilren's Lit class) and that might have something to do with it. But I stand by my words.
 
A clumsy introduction to a great trilogy ***
While I am just wrapping up book two, I have to say that The Golden Compass was, in itself, the more diluted book. I understand he's setting up the world(s) and characters, but some parts were dull and dry. In this, the book loses focus of some of its subtler elements, but the series jumps back into the fray and focus of them in its sequel, The Subtle Knife.

The characters, however, are all quite unique and don't fall to cliché as often as other books. I like that he doesn't child-proof this for a generation intent on keeping their children bubble-wrapped "for their own good."
 
This is the first book in the Dark Materials story. *****
It is not worth reviewing or reading the reviews of "The Golden Compass" (British title "The Northern Lights") until one has finished the complete story of "Dark Materials" by Philip Pullman.

As with any genre the author is trying to express a concept or make a point. By using the genre, whether it is westerns sci-fi or historic peace, the author envelops the concept in a palatable story. Sometimes the envelope completely masks the purpose of the story; at other times the purpose is so blatant that one doesn't even know why anything was being enveloped. This is one of those rare stories that polarize readers from one extreme to the other.

We recognize and other phenomena about this story. In many stories the reader rule look at the antagonists are protagonist and once in awhile can sympathize but never recognizes themselves as the protagonist. In Philip Pullman's his "Dark Materials" it seems that everybody recognizes themselves with an "if the shoe fits attitude" whether it is really them or not.

Now dark materials, book one "The Golden Compass." Lyra who ran wild around Jordan Collage at Oxford is now hiding in a closet in the Retiring Room. There she sees that the Master is about to poison her uncle Lord Asriel. Now Lyra must figure out who are the good guys from the bad, if there are good and bad guys. In the process she fund find and fulfill her destiny without fully realizing what that destiny is. The people and creatures around her know more of her destiny than she does. Soon she must leave Jordon College and is given a beautiful golden instrument with pictures and arms that resemble a compass. What she is supposed to do with it is not clear at first.
 
I can't believe how much I enjoyed this book ****
I can't believe how much I enjoyed this book, even though it's supposed to be part of a children's series.
The story moves at a fast pace and there are quite a few darker element to this story, so I would probably recommend it for grades 6 and up. The Golden Compass which is the first of 3 books known as Phillip Pullmans "his dark Materials" is also supposed to be released as a movie this year. Can't wait to see how they capture it on screen.

The story revolves around Lyra Belacqua who ends up on a dark adventure trying to find her friend Roger who was kidnapped by The Gobblers. She meets many interesting people on her journey, including witches and armoured bears. The story takes part in a world very similar to ours, except in Lyra's world every human being has a daemon, which is essentially their soul in animal form.
I can't wait to see where the journey leads us in "The Subtle Knife".

Tachyos.org  |  Chronon Critical Points  |  Recent Science Book Reviews