Show Book List  | More books by Philip Pullman

Reviews from Amazon
Amazon.com (0440238137) 1473 reviews
Amazon.com (0590660543) 1473 reviews
Amazon.co.uk (0590660543) 647 reviews
Amazon.co.uk (0440238137) 647 reviews
Amazon.ca (0440238137) 1090 reviews
Amazon.ca (0590660543) 1090 reviews
A selection of these reviews is given below

 

Philip Pullman

The Golden Compass

'The Golden Compass' (or 'Northern Lights' as the version I read was titled) is the first book of Philip Pullman's 'His Dark Materials' trilogy. It's the story of Lyra Belacqua, who spends most of her time playing around the Oxford college where she lives. But her playmates are being kidnapped, and her decision to rescue them draws her into much wider conflicts. Pullman shows such inventiveness in creating a new world for his story that it's sometimes hard to put the book down. But Pullman's books haven't had the same kind of bestselling success as some other books of a similar genre. I think part of the reason for this is that Pullman isn't really sure who he is writing for.

Lyra is around twelve years old, and the action in the book suggests that this is sort of age it is aimed at. But Pullman seems to have a negative take on a lot of things - religion, science, parenting, and I think this would make me wary of giving it as a gift to someone of that age. There's also a lot of nostalgia for a bygone age, implying an older audience. I think if I had read it when I was twelve then I would have found it very confusing. But if you are an older reader who has realised that some children's books don't seem so childish after all then you should give Pullman's work a try.

Amazon.com info
Mass Market Paperback 368 pages  
ISBN: 0440238137
Salesrank: 254443
Weight:0.25 lbs
Published: 2003 Laurel Leaf
Amazon price $7.50
Marketplace:New from $0.99:Used from $0.01
Buy from Amazon.com
Amazon.co.uk info
Paperback 416 pages  
ISBN: 0590660543
Salesrank: 58567
Weight:0.66 lbs
Published: 1998 Scholastic Point
Marketplace:New from £1.12:Used from £0.01
Buy from Amazon.co.uk
Amazon.ca info
Mass Market Paperback 368 pages  
ISBN: 0440238137
Salesrank: 71941
Weight:0.25 lbs
Published: 2003 Laurel Leaf
Amazon price CDN$ 9.99
Marketplace:New from CDN$ 1.80:Used from CDN$ 0.01
Buy from Amazon.ca

Product Description
Lyra Belaqua is content to run wild among the scholars of Jordan College, with her daemon familiar Pantalaimon always by her side. But the arrival of her fearsome uncle, Lord Asriel, draws her to the heart of a terrible struggle—a struggle born of Gobblers and stolen children, witch clans and armored bears. And as she hurtles toward danger in the cold, far North, young Lyra never suspects the shocking truth: She alone is destined to win, or to lose, this more-than-mortal battle.
 
I was told not to read it so I did *****
Seriously, I kept hearing how terrible this series was. So I had to see for myself what all the hype was about. I think my praise would be lost in the sea of accolades already bestowed upon this work. So I'm not going to repeat what everyone else has been saying. I'll just say, "Ditto!"
One thing I will say is this, don't let anyone tell you to judge something without having the insight and knowledge to make your own educated decision. And remember sheep have no choice but to fear the wolves because they can't think or reason for themselves. If you can think and reason, works of art such as this one only improve whatever faith you have chosen. Fear is the real enemy! As it happens, acting in the face of fear is a very important theme in this story which is refreshing and enlightening.
 
I'm glad I read this one! *****
The Golden Compass is the first of Philip Pullman's His Dark Materials trilogy. It is a story about a girl named Lyra who lives at Jordan College and has a best friend named Roger. Many children dissappear including her friend Roger, and she goes on an adventure to try and find out what happened to them. This book contains magic, adventure, witches, daemons, bears and all kinds of other interesting things. The end sets up for an exciting beginning in the second book. I cant wait to read it! I have not seen the movie, but now that is something else on my list of things to do.
 
Listen, people. ****
I didn't want to go into the whole "religious" aspect of these books, but after reading all the reviews I can't help myself. The fact is that Pullman's series is really good. It's intriguing, entertaining, and engaging. I wouldn't go so far as to say that it's better than Rowling's Harry Potter series (to which it has been compared), but I found myself becoming attached to the characters, hoping for their victory. Now that that's out of the way, let me say that I am a Christian. Shocking, I know. I read the books almost hesitantly, always expecting to be disgusted and turned off by the religious "bigotry" that so many speak of. Was I eating up all the "anti-Christian" stuff? No. But then again, I wasn't terribly offended. It's Pullman's opinions and beliefs being expressed via finely-written fiction. I can deal with that and I can't bring myself to speak negatively of these books simply because of the religious undertones. I just hate to see people who share my faith unable to grasp that these are works of FICTION and then attack those who actually found the stories entertaining. I guess, in my mind, my faith is strong enough to where I can accept that others have different beliefs than me and not have a heart attack about it. But back to the books. Please don't NOT read them, if you're a Christian, based on the negative reviews of those people who condemn these wonderful books based on their religious undertones. I mean, to say that His Dark Materials is bad based on its religious bias would be to condemn works such as The Chronicles of Narnia, which also have a religious bias. They just take a different viewpoint.
 
Pleasantly Surprised *****
After the negative publicity surronding the release of the movie "The Golden Compass", I was inclined to dismiss it. However, after watching the movie on TV, I wanted to read the books.

To say "I was impressed" would be an understatement! Captivated from the first few pages, it was evident that I was reading an author to rival the likes of J.R.R. Tolkien (for the depth of the characters) and
J.K. Rowling (for the creation of an alternative world of persuasive reality).

"The Golden Compass" is excellent and the three book series exceeds all expectations.
 
Golden Compass - classic fantasy *****
Aside from Harry Potter, Philip Pullman's His Dark Materials series is one of my all-time favorite fantasies. In the first part of the trilogy, we are introduced to the young heroine Lyra and a world in which all humans have a physical soul in animal form called a daemon. Lyra and her daemon, Pan, are content to cause trouble at their home of Jordan College...until children in Oxford and nearby towns start to disappear. Then everything begins to happen at once: Lyra foils an assassination plot, one of her own friends is snatched, the beautiful Mrs. Coulter enters her life - and somehow, everything revolves around the mystic particles known as Dust. As they seek to unravel the mystery, Lyra and Pan are swept along in an adventure that ranges from awe-inspiring to terrifying.
 
Marvellous stuff for children and adults alike *****
Great stuff, a gripping adventure. For adults, a major plus is seeing the greater and lesser ways in which the universe in which the action takes place differs from our own universe.
 
An okay book ***
I found this book quite slow in the beginning but once I got into the story I did enjoy it. This book has a good plot and some great characters but I was a little bit dissappointed with the ending.
 
Slow start, great finish ****
I tried starting this a couple of times but for some reason never got past the first few pages. However, once I managed to get into it I thoroughly enjoyed it.

Considering the grown-up nature of the trilogy, Northern Lights starts off reasonably childishly - easy to see the Harry Potter comparisons what with all the witches, daemons etc.

Much more of a standard 'adventure' book than the other two in the series.
 
A decent but difficult children's book - (No Spoilers) ***
To justify my score, I am reviewing this book as A CHILDREN'S BOOK and so its appeal to adults will not be considered in the review. Secondly in the Roger Ebert tradition I have tried to place the score acordingly in the correct context. Thirdly my personal oppinion is a factor. The score is a 3.5 (a 7/10).

Anyway... lets get started.

The Good:
-Imaginative Ideas and Concept:- Philip Pullman's ideas and concepts are easily the highlight of this book (and subsequent sequels) with some truly fantastic thoughts in here. This should get children's imaginations going haywire. However a lot of his "terminology" like Naphtha and Anbaric will probably confuse children.
-Some solid characters
-Flowing narrative with adequate amounts of action
-Engaging Storyline:- The story has a solid destination reached by the end of the book and the goal or "quest" (I love that word) of the protagonist is made fairly early on in the book which is good.


The Not-So-Good:
-A few weak characters: Roger is a good example
-I didn't like Lyra:- Infact I think Philip Pullman should have called her "Lie-ra" seeing that that is pretty much the only natural talent she is shown to possess in the course of this book.
-Lots of Descriptive writing:- This isn't a bad thing if you are reading adult fantasy like Lord of the Rings but this is a children's book.
-Humor (or lack thereof):-I wasn't expecting the next A.A. Mille but considering the target audience....anyway Pullman's humor was lacking in both quantity and quality.
-Its sequels are better (particularly "The Subtle Knife" which is much more focused) and there are much "faster" paced children's books out there.
-Hard to understand:- Children will not get references to peoples and locations in the real world (Svalbard, Tartars, etc). In Dracula (an adult's book) it tells you what Tokay is in the glossery, in this book it doesn't (there is not even a glossery). The only thing that makes this a children's book really is the fact that the protagonist is a child.

But do I recommend this book? Yes I do, and as I said, Pullman's ideas are really something and many children will love it. On the other hand its a pretty difficult book with all the crazy terminology readers have to learn (no glossery), its quite difficult to read and it is slightly lacking in areas.

The best is to come though, the Subtle Knife and The Amber Spyglass are better.




 
Lifes too short! *
After the amazing reviews this book has received I was really excited to start reading it and it started off really good. However, I found Lyra a very unconvincing character and not particularly likeable and it was this character that really finished my reading of the book. I gave up about fifty pages before the end as really life is too short to waste on such a boring book.
 
Not Impressed ***
Lower class children are disappearing and when Lyra finds that her friend is missing she wants to find him and get him back. Lyra becomes caught up in her new life but eventually realizes that all is not as it seems and those she trusts are involved with the disappearance of the children. Lyra goes on a quest which ultimately results in her following her destiny. I wanted to like this book much more than I did. Honestly, I wasn't even close to blown away. The story was slow to start. Lyra was the only fleshed-out main character and I wasn't fond of her at all. Boring is the word that comes to mind. The book also ends with a cliff-hanger which is a technique I really do not appreciate.

I'm not saying this was a bad book though. Once the the pace picked up, I did find the story interesting and parts did read quickly. I'm finding it difficult to write this review as nothing really stood out to me as being great. It was ok; but I doubt I'll read the other books.
 
what's to rave about? ***
There are many people who liked this book, but I for one am not that impressed. I'm not saying it's horrible because it's not. It's a good read with an interesting concept, but compared to so many great children's literature out there, it's really not well written. Lyra isn't very likable as a character and Pullman's fantasy world is not very original let alone captivating.
I admit I didn't read this book by choice (it was for my Chilren's Lit class) and that might have something to do with it. But I stand by my words.
 
A clumsy introduction to a great trilogy ***
While I am just wrapping up book two, I have to say that The Golden Compass was, in itself, the more diluted book. I understand he's setting up the world(s) and characters, but some parts were dull and dry. In this, the book loses focus of some of its subtler elements, but the series jumps back into the fray and focus of them in its sequel, The Subtle Knife.

The characters, however, are all quite unique and don't fall to cliché as often as other books. I like that he doesn't child-proof this for a generation intent on keeping their children bubble-wrapped "for their own good."
 
This is the first book in the Dark Materials story. *****
It is not worth reviewing or reading the reviews of "The Golden Compass" (British title "The Northern Lights") until one has finished the complete story of "Dark Materials" by Philip Pullman.

As with any genre the author is trying to express a concept or make a point. By using the genre, whether it is westerns sci-fi or historic peace, the author envelops the concept in a palatable story. Sometimes the envelope completely masks the purpose of the story; at other times the purpose is so blatant that one doesn't even know why anything was being enveloped. This is one of those rare stories that polarize readers from one extreme to the other.

We recognize and other phenomena about this story. In many stories the reader rule look at the antagonists are protagonist and once in awhile can sympathize but never recognizes themselves as the protagonist. In Philip Pullman's his "Dark Materials" it seems that everybody recognizes themselves with an "if the shoe fits attitude" whether it is really them or not.

Now dark materials, book one "The Golden Compass." Lyra who ran wild around Jordan Collage at Oxford is now hiding in a closet in the Retiring Room. There she sees that the Master is about to poison her uncle Lord Asriel. Now Lyra must figure out who are the good guys from the bad, if there are good and bad guys. In the process she fund find and fulfill her destiny without fully realizing what that destiny is. The people and creatures around her know more of her destiny than she does. Soon she must leave Jordon College and is given a beautiful golden instrument with pictures and arms that resemble a compass. What she is supposed to do with it is not clear at first.
 
I can't believe how much I enjoyed this book ****
I can't believe how much I enjoyed this book, even though it's supposed to be part of a children's series.
The story moves at a fast pace and there are quite a few darker element to this story, so I would probably recommend it for grades 6 and up. The Golden Compass which is the first of 3 books known as Phillip Pullmans "his dark Materials" is also supposed to be released as a movie this year. Can't wait to see how they capture it on screen.

The story revolves around Lyra Belacqua who ends up on a dark adventure trying to find her friend Roger who was kidnapped by The Gobblers. She meets many interesting people on her journey, including witches and armoured bears. The story takes part in a world very similar to ours, except in Lyra's world every human being has a daemon, which is essentially their soul in animal form.
I can't wait to see where the journey leads us in "The Subtle Knife".

Tachyos.org  |  Chronon Critical Points  |  Recent Science Book Reviews