Show Book List

Reviews elsewhere on the web:
CentralBanking.com
Danny Yee
Risk Watchdog
Here is the city
Emergent Futures

Riccardo Rebonato

Plight of the fortune tellers

Banks have lost huge amounts of money in the last few years, but why? They were subject to regulations and employed risk managers, and so things shouldn't have got anything like so bad. Why did things go so wrong? In Plight of the Fortune Tellers: Why We Need to Manage Financial Risk Differently Riccardo Rebonato gives his explanation.

Many people see the repackaging of risking investments into new financial instruments as a large part of the problem but Rebonato disagrees - he sees such instruments as a good way of managing risk rather than a problem. Instead he sees the poblem as the belief in risk estimates with little basis in reality. The 99.9th percentile represents a risk which happens only once in a thousand years - how can we have a realistic estimate of such risks with only a few year's data. The distribution of such long tail risks can be very different from the Gaussian distribution which is often assumed by default. Also the use of frequentist statistical methods gives a false assurance about the estimates - Rebonato recommends Bayesian statistics for a more realistic estimate of risk.

The book makes important points, but after the first few chapters I felt it was just saying the same thing in several different ways. I would have liked more discussion of the ideas presented. For instance should repackaging risk get off the hook so easily or does managing risk mean hiding risk? The book seemed to me to be aimed more at the financial practitioner than at the reader interested in what went wrong with the economy - indeed as the first edition of the book was published 5 years ago, it's a pity that many more financial practioners didn't read it then.

Amazon.com info
Paperback 328 pages  
ISBN: 0691148171
Salesrank: 1557780
Weight:1.05 lbs
Published: 2010 Princeton University Press
Amazon price $21.56
Marketplace:New from $15.38:Used from $12.51
Buy from Amazon.com
Amazon.co.uk info
Paperback 328 pages  
ISBN: 0691148171
Salesrank: 1374692
Weight:1.05 lbs
Published: 2010 Princeton University Press
Amazon price £15.55
Marketplace:New from £10.94:Used from £11.34
Buy from Amazon.co.uk
Amazon.ca info
Paperback 328 pages  
ISBN: 0691148171
Salesrank: 669775
Weight:1.05 lbs
Published: 2010 Princeton University Press
Amazon price CDN$ 28.95
Marketplace:New from CDN$ 20.50:Used from CDN$ 23.37
Buy from Amazon.ca





Product Description

Today's top financial professionals have come to rely on ever-more sophisticated mathematics in their attempts to come to grips with financial risk. But this excessive reliance on quantitative precision is misleading--and puts everyone at risk. In Plight of the Fortune Tellers, Riccardo Rebonato forcefully argues that we must restore genuine decision making to our financial planning. Presenting a financial model that uses probability, experimental psychology, and decision theory, Rebonato challenges us to rethink the standard wisdom about risk management. He offers a radical yet surprisingly commonsense solution: managing risk comes down to real people making decisions under uncertainty.

Plight of the Fortune Tellers is a must-read for anyone concerned about how today's financial markets are run. In a new preface, Rebonato explains how the ideas presented in this book fit into the context of the global financial crisis that followed its original publication. He argues that risk managers are still stuck in a probabilistic rut, and need to engage with the structural causes of real events.


Tachyos.org  |  Chronon Critical Points  |  Recent Science Book Reviews