Show Book List

Reviews from Amazon
Amazon.co.uk (1841957550) 4 reviews
A selection of these reviews is given below

Reviews elsewhere on the web:
Roddy Lumsden

Charles Maclean

Island on the Edge of the World

Island on the Edge of the World: The Story of St Kilda by Charles Maclean tells of a remote group of islands of the coast of Scotland, and of the people who lived there.

St Kilda was peopled in prehistoric times, but its known history starts when it came into the ownership of the MacLeod family of Harris in the 14thcentury. The owners would occasionally send a steward to the island, but it was a difficult and dangerous journey, so mostly the islanders were left to fend for themselves. Thus there arose a unique culture there. The islands were poorly suited for inhabitants, and so the main food was the seabirds which went there in great numbers. Skill in climbing the dangerous crags in order to catch the birds was vital. It was a hard life, but it seems that with the coming of missionaries in the 18th century it became even harder - there were so many restrictions imposed by religion. As time went on the contrast between island life and life elsewhere became too great, and in 1930 the islanders moved off the island to join the rest of society.

Maclean spends a chapter bemoaning the loss of such a culture, but it is hard to see how things could have been otherwise - the chapter is more of a rant than a considered argument. What I found interesting about the book was that it wasn't the story of sudden contact with the rest of the world, rather it was limited contact over a very long time. Hence it is possible to see what effect this contact is having. Whether you are interested in this aspect of the book, or just want to hear about life on a remote island, I would say that the book is well worth reading.

Amazon.com info
Paperback 210 pages  
ISBN: 1841957550
Salesrank: 4711292
Weight:0.44 lbs
Published: 2006 Canongate Books
Marketplace::Used from $4.98
Buy from Amazon.com
Amazon.co.uk info
Paperback 210 pages  
ISBN: 1841957550
Salesrank: 112821
Weight:0.44 lbs
Published: 2006 Canongate Books Ltd
Amazon price £5.22
Marketplace:New from £3.20:Used from £1.93
Buy from Amazon.co.uk
Amazon.ca info
Paperback 210 pages  
ISBN: 1841957550
Salesrank:
Weight:0.44 lbs
Published: 2009 CANONGATE
Amazon price CDN$ 18.00
Marketplace:New from CDN$ 17.99:Used from CDN$ 3.98
Buy from Amazon.ca






 
Full of information but chronologically confusing at times ****
I wanted to find out more about St Kilda, the St Kildans and their history and this book cetainly contained lots of information. I particularly enjoyed the excerpts from earlier writings by travellers to St Kilda from hundreds of years ago and the book answered lots of questions I'd had. However, it did jump around from era to era and I found myself having to refer back to earlier chapters to try to fit what I was reading into a time line.

It was definitely thought provoking and I was both entertained and depressed by trying to imagine what the St Kildans' day to day lives would have been like and what their thoughts might have been.

Well worth buying!
 
Fascinating look at an isolated society *****
Fascinating look at this tiny island and its isolated community. Also an interesting study of the way societies react to change from without and how larger societies seek to influence smaller ones.
 
Great synopsis of the St Kilda story ****
A fantastic introduction to the islands collectively known as St Kilda. I've read several books about St Kilda and this interpretation combines readability and historical statistics just about perfectly. If you want to read your first book on St Kilda, you can't go far wrong with this.
 
Well, that's one view! **
I found this book drab and uninteresting among many better texts on the history of the island.

There are much better books to buy on what is a fantastic place with real history and which deserves a more imaginative commentary.

Poor.

Tachyos.org  |  Chronon Critical Points  |  Recent Science Book Reviews