Show Book List

Reviews from Amazon
Amazon.com (0441172717) 1061 reviews
Amazon.com (0450011844) 1061 reviews
Amazon.co.uk (0450011844) 89 reviews
Amazon.co.uk (0441172717) 89 reviews
Amazon.ca (0441172717) 851 reviews
Amazon.ca (0450011844) 851 reviews
A selection of these reviews is given below

Reviews elsewhere on the web:
Nicholas Whyte
Tamara I. Hladik
Chronicles-network
Lisa Shea
Aaron M. Renn

Frank Herbert

Dune

Dune by Frank Herbert, is a classic scifi novel which has spawned a considerable number of sequels and quite a few imitators. The story is centred around Paul Atreides, son of Leto, Duke of the planet Caladan. The Atreides have a long emnity with the evil Harkonnen family, and at the start of the story the galactic emperor has decreed that the two families should exchange homeworlds, so that the Atreides get Arrakis, source of the spice vital to the workings of the empire, and so of immense wealth. A just reward for moral behaviour? - no, Leto sees clearly that it is a trap, which may mean the end of the Atreides family.

Indeed Paul and his mother Jessica have to escape to the inhospitable desert of Arrakis, which is occupied only by the secretive and dangerous Fremen population. Until now the Fremen people have been considered to be of little importance in galactic affairs, but that is about to change.

Although Dune is clearly in the science fiction category, it is nothing like the space opera that this suggests. Technology plays a minor role in the story, and much of what happens is more akin to magic. The book can be confusing, with the constant intrugues between different factions, and it's the sort of book which may need to be read several times to make sense of it - but it's such a classic work that this is worth the effort.

Amazon.com info
Paperback 544 pages  
ISBN: 0441172717
Salesrank: 41234
Weight:0.6 lbs
Published: 1990 Ace
Amazon price $7.99
Marketplace:New from $4.27:Used from $0.01
Buy from Amazon.com
Amazon.co.uk info
Paperback 608 pages  
ISBN: 0450011844
Salesrank: 2993
Weight:0.66 lbs
Published: 1982 Hodder Paperbacks
Amazon price £5.99
Marketplace:New from £2.92:Used from £0.01
Buy from Amazon.co.uk
Amazon.ca info
Paperback 544 pages  
ISBN: 0441172717
Salesrank: 2327
Weight:0.6 lbs
Published: 1990 Ace (MM)
Amazon price CDN$ 8.99
Marketplace:New from CDN$ 1.25:Used from CDN$ 0.01
Buy from Amazon.ca






Product Description
Paul Atreides moves with his family to the planet Dune and is forced into exile when his father's government is overthrown. The first book in the series.
 
Kindle Version: Flawless *****
This is a review of the Kindle Version.

Dune is arguably the best science fiction series of all time. I won't go into a more detailed review because there are over 1000 on Amazon and I can add little to the discussion.

What I will review is the Kindle Version of this book. It is flawless, an exact clean copy. (I have the original Dune in paperback, and have read it several times). This Kindle version is perfect, down to the same misspellings in the original paper book. The fonts are even similar, including the slightly different font in the preludes to each chapter. This may seem trivial, but it the number of errors in Kindle versions of books like this is astounding.

Some might quibble over the pricing, because if you really wanted to, you could get a paperback version cheaper than the Kindle version. However, to me, the value of having all of the Dune books in a nice thin package of the Kindle more than makes it worth the extra buck.

There is a interesting point in the book in which Paul Atriedes gets a tiny little scroll-like reader of the O.C. Bible as a gift. He had to use some type of magnifying device to read it. This was, ironically, one of the only future technology concepts that Frank Herbert "guessed wrong" about. Funny - even the most forward-looking science fiction writers could not foresee the magic of the Kindle!
 
Not for Star Trek fans *****
I always find it instructing to start with the one and two stars reviews, when I try to form an opinion... Herbert's writing skills and his characters are the favorite targets of these reviewers. Many of the reviews here are based on a hidden presupposition that all readers share the reviewer's view of the world. They are not literary criticism, but rather philosophical critiques. IF one happens to agree with, or is persuaded in the process by Herbert's arguments, swayed to his weltanschauung so to speak, then the plot and the characters are VERY adequate, being intensely allegorical yet realistic, in a fractal-like relationship, in which the individual microcosm is reiterated to ever larger encompassing structures/universes. If you don't think the universe is funny, if you don't buy into poetic justice and the noble savage fairy tales, if your view of the world is realistic - as in positivistic, scientific and pragmatic - then your reaction to Dune is bound to be different and the author's literary craftsmanship (or lack thereof) will have nothing to do with it.
As far as his writing skill is concerned, many seem to find his omniscient, character shifting third person lacking, in that it prevents one from empathizing with one character or another. I find it brilliant and a delightful tour-de-force, with so many points of view in the same scene and each character a mirror to the others.
This book is not for Star Trek fans. It is not uplifting, it does not speak of the glory of Man, it is not about exploration, it does not serve any system's propaganda. On the contrary, it is anti-establishment in a broad sense and anti-democratic to the extreme... On second thought, it should be banned! :) Burn it! :)))
 
AMAZON IS CHARGING ALMOST $4.00 ABOVE LIST FOR THIS BOOK *
Click on the "look inside" folks and you'll see the PRICE on the back: $7.99. Go to Barnes and Noble: $7.99

I am a loyal Amazon customer and a Prime member. As far as I am concerned this is unacceptable. Vote with your wallet and shop elsewhere for this.
 
Passé! ***
This work is very much a product of the 1960's and, though set in the distant future, appears somewhat quaint in 2010.

Indeed, it is odd to see characters with the technology to travel through space but without cell phones or computers. Social and political organization is akin to early medieval times and totally remote of any democratic pretence. There are human servants about and no signs whatsoever of robots. For reasons that are beyond me, as if in the theatre, knives and poison constitute weapons of choice.

The audio book's production is far from outstanding: various actors are called upon to impersonate the many characters and all are not equally convincing. The problem may lie in the direction as the tone changes often considerably from one to the other. Possibly, the different parts were taped separately and edited together subsequently.

Contrary to my expectations, this work stands no comparison with the Lord of the Rings series in terms of imagination, depth or significance. Some may however find it entertaining.
 
Strong, Imaginative World ****
Long before "Star Wars" presented us with a desert world of adventure and intrigue (and for some reason cute creatures who can make a living salvaging robots for scrap on a world that doesn't seem to have much industry and therefore need of robots...), Frank Herbert gave us "Dune." It's considered a classic, and "Dune" is definitely a triumph in world-building, with giant worms and clever bodysuits that capture precious water, the most valuable commodity in such a place. It's also got an intricate plot filled with political machinations that keep the reader on their toes; you can't just breeze through this one and expect all the answers to fall into your lap.

The sole weakness in "Dune," at least for me, lay in its characterization. There are far too many two-dimensional characters in this novel, and far too few gray three-dimensional ones (Dr. Yueh was the only one I took any real interest in). This hampers the novel's story, since it limits how much each character can grow and develop. I suppose this is why I can remember Arrakis as a place so clearly, while Paul Atredies is only a blur. I did enjoy the references to family-owned nuclear weapons, though.
 
Unsurpassed *****
I first read this when I was in my late teens and I was utterly blown away by it. It has been re-read roughly every two years since until the prequels/sequels/interquels came out and my Dune fixation was satisfied for a while. since news of a new movie adaptation has reached me I have started it again and within a few pages I am reminded of why it made such an impact on me all those years ago. Just how one man managed to get so many ideas into one book escapes me.

I have tried to compare it to other classics and I really can't. Foundation left me cold. Ringworld was clever but a bit sterile. Lord of the Rings, whilst brilliant in it's scope, still doesn't have the WOW factor that Dune has.

If you don't like this book you should go back to your Practical Needlecraft magazines.
 
"Dune" *****

There is probably not much value in reviewing classic books like 'Dune', which people have either read and loved or had no interest in and ignored. It would be a great shame if there is anyone in the latter category, because 'Dune' is one of the greatest pieces of genre fiction of all time, successfully creating a fusion of science-fiction, adventure and political drama that does not fail to keep you enthralled from cover to cover.

Not to waste too much of any potential buyer's time, my advice is to buy it and read it. Herbert was one of the world's greatest writers and storytellers and the Dune series is his masterpiece. A brilliant novel in its own right that has already been adapted twice for screen with a third epic remake on the way, I urge everyone to read the first book for the complete "true" Dune story, and the sequels if, like everyone else, you were hooked.

10 / 10

David Brookes
Author of "Half Discovered Wings"
 
A Book of Wisdom and Strength *****
The harsh, desolate planet of Dune. No crystal clear water falls or beautiful green fields here. Just rivers of dry, hard corrosive sand and the little particles of water recycled by your stillsuite. Live by the crysknife. Live by your wits. Only the strong survive!

And there are definitely many strong characters here:


The Bene Gesserits: An exclusive sisterhood whose members train their bodies and minds through years of physical and mental conditioning. With enhanced awareness and senses they can control a person with one word. And their goal: to breed a person they label `Kwisatz Haderach', a term meaning `one who can be many places at once.' `In simpler terms, what they sought was a human with mental powers permitting him to understand and use higher order dimensions.' Is the young Paul Atreides the Kwisatz Haderach they've been waiting for?

Mentats: Humans trained to mimic computers. They have the uncanny ability for precise calculation without emotion, and to clearly see motives.

The Freman: In the harshest conditions of Dune, they survive and thrive with fierce fighting abilities.


This is a novel about human possibilities and potential. The potential of the mind. Of controlling the mind. Of learning. Of how to learn. On superior training:


`Muad'Dib' knew that every experience carries its lesson.'

`At the age of 15, he had already learned silence.'

`If you rely only on your eyes, your other senses weaken.'

`Fear is the mind-killer. Fear is the little death that brings total obliteration. I will face my fear. I will permit it to pass over me and through me. And when the fear has gone there will be nothing. Only I will remain.

`The mind can go either direction under stress - towards positive or towards negative: on or off. Think of it as a spectrum whose extremes are unconsciousness at the negative end and hyperconsciousness at the positive end. The way the mind will lean under stress is strongly influenced by training.'


And you must adapt. Evolve. Learn, and fast! There is no welfare, shielding liberal protective state here. That breeds weakness. There is no place for weakness in Dune, as the Old Reverend mother states when she snaps at Jessica: `Shield! You well know the weakness there! Shield your son too much, Jessica, and he'll not grow strong enough to fulfil any destiny.'


In Dune you become strong with pain. You learn by pain. Hallecks inkvine scar along his jawline, always a reminder. Paul's aching hand from the gom jabber. Can you take the pain? No. Then you die!

A novel about leadership and ruling:


As the Old Reverend mother tells Paul `Grave this on your memory, lad: A world is supported by four things ...' "She held up four big-knuckled fingers." `... the learning of the wise, the justice of the great, the prayers of the righteous and the valour of the brave. But all of these are as nothing ...' She closed her fingers into a fist. `... without a ruler who knows the art of ruling. Make that the science of your tradition!'


And a novel about ecological consequences, with the environmental concerns of Dune's inhabitants analogous to our own:


`Beyond a critical point within a finite space, freedom diminishes as numbers increase. This is as true of humans in the finite space of a planetary ecosystem as it is of gas molecules in a sealed flask. The human question is not how many can possibly survive within the system, but what kind of existence is possible for those who do survive.'

`We came from Caladan - a paradise for our form of life. There existed no need on Caladan to build a physical paradise or a paradise of the mind - we could see the actuality all around us. And the price we paid was the price men have always paid for achieving a paradise in this life - we went soft, we lost our edge.'


Have we been too ignorant for too long about our own planets ecology? `The highest function of ecology is the understanding of consequences.' Do we understand the consequences of what we have and are doing to our own planet? To our paradise? Have we become too soft? Have we lost our edge?

Frank Herbert created a world from the bottom up, and it is vast and brilliant. For every reader of this book, this world exists. It is real, in the dark depths of our minds. Let's hope that is where it stays.
 
It is a classic - but not that great ***
Dune is a classic of science fiction. When I read it first I was captivated the desert world and the philosophy of the Fremen who lived there. But I remember thinking the writing was hard work. Forty years later I thought I would revisit it, and it was a real disapointment. The world of Arakis is still as well written as it was then, but Frank Herbert wrote a novel which gave the reader knowledge of all and every characters point of view. So if a scene has three characters, the reader recieves their dialogue and also their thoughts and motivations. For modern readers this has the effect of changing protagonists every few seconds. It makes it hard to identify with anyone. The world and universe is deeply and convincingly described. I think that is what has kept this books popularity, not the characterisation or writing style.
 
Astonishing! *****
The other reviews seem to say it all. This book is timeless, and despite being written in the 60s it deals with issues that are even more relevant today than they were at the time Frank put pen to paper. To class it as sci-fi novel seems a shame to me as it will stop people sampling a book that is a true classic.
I was actually put off reading the book for many years after seeing David Lynch's movie Dune. The movie was average at best and I couldn't understand the praise that the book had received. How wrong I was!
I eventually got round to reading it at University and was soon amazed at the fantastic story, characters and setting. The depth and nuances of the universe that Herbert creates is quite simply a work of pure genius. I've read it a number of times since and each time I pick up something new. I've even got my girlfriend to read it and she loved it despite never having a thing for sci fi books.
The thing is that although Dune is fantastically clever and operates on many levels, it is first and foremost a great read. The best description is a swashbuckling page turner that will draw you deep into the Dune universe and leave you feeling sad when you turn over that final page and realise that its time to leave. I'm not going to waste time spelling out the story when so many others have done so before me. I'll just give you one piece of advice, buy it you wont regret it.
 
It's an absolutely wonderful, engrossing book. *****
Dune is a wonderful book. It completely engrosses the reader, giving one an experience similar to the one which the human characters experience in the Avatar film when they are inside the world of their avatars on the planet. When you stop reading, it's like coming out of the avatar pod into the real world, you can't wait to enter the world of dune again. Dune is also a fascinating study of desert ecology, water conservation, and how desert dwellers (including humans) adapt to their environment. It is also a reprimand to humanity for becoming too dependant on technology, robotics (robots) and machinery, and forgetting how to take care of themselves. As well as a lesson that teaches us that city dwellers have become estranged from the environment (nature) and became maladapted to surviving, to say nothing of living outside their cities with all their environmental and plush residential fluff. (while reading this review, mind that the book was originally published in 1965, Herbert seems to have foreseen the ecological problems, and technological advances of today!) Dune
 
Dune series *****
I was thrilled to find a hardcover copy of this novel. It was the only one in the series that I was missing.
 
Epic Masterpiece *****
Not much more can be said about this book than has already been said. I finally read it after countless recommendations and putting it off for years. I was skeptical that it would be as good as everyone said it is, but it is. Frank Herbert shows himself to be a keen observer of human nature, political intrigue and conspiracy, religion, and the depths and variations of human emotion. His characters are believable and range from psychopathic and ruthless, to morally weak and conformist, to courageous and authentic. Complex, expansive, moving, and exceedingly well written. I can't wait to finish the series.
 
Comparative to LOTR? *****
While it is quite true that comparing this series to that of LOTR is a bit absurd, I will not bow down to the opinions of those who believe Dune doesn't hold a candle to LOTR. In risk of being redundant, I disagree with the opinion that Dune does not delve deeply enough into the characters, or that they are comparably to cheap commercials. The largest issue people have with Dune, especially those who find it boring, is that they simply cannot grasp the various theories being played out through the novel. If you consider yourself a strong reader, a philosopher, and a person of many angles who isn't reliant on the straightforwardness of "good" versus "evil" as many of a lower intelligence are, this is the read for you. This book will keep your mind sharp throughout its read, and you might even learn something about the time chaos theory.

Tachyos.org  |  Chronon Critical Points  |  Recent Science Book Reviews