Show Book List

Reviews from Amazon
Amazon.co.uk (0241141346) 4 reviews
Amazon.co.uk (0140299866) 3 reviews
A selection of these reviews is given below

 

Paul Strathern

Dr Strangelove's Game

We all have our ideas on how to put the world to rights, in particular on how money should be distributed. Various economic ideas have taken hold over the centuries, with differing degrees of success. In Dr Strangelove's Game Paul Strathern tells the stories of some of the originators of these economic theories.

He tells of the early ideas of people such as John Graunt and John Law, and of how Adam Smith put economics on a firm footing. In the 19th century there are thinkers such as Jeremy Bentham and Karl Marx, and in the early 20th John Maynard Keynes and Thorstein Veblen. This leads to 'Dr Strangelove' himself John von Neumann and on the the more recent game theoretic ideas of John Nash.

I felt that Strathern let his politics colour his writing a bit too much, for instance in his criticism of Adam Smith, and indeed in the identification of von Neumann with Dr. Strangelove. Also the title suggested to me that it would be a book about 20th century economics and game theory, when in fact it's mostly about earlier economists. But it provides a useful overview of how economics has developed over the centuries, expecially for those who don't want to get into the technical details. Also, to come up with original economic ideas you need to be someone who stands apart from the crowd, and the stories of such people are always interesting.

Amazon.com info
Paperback 352 pages  
ISBN: 0140299866
Salesrank: 2939386
Weight:0.56 lbs
Published: 2002 Penguin Books Ltd
Marketplace::Used from $11.97
Buy from Amazon.com
Amazon.co.uk info
Hardcover 336 pages  
ISBN: 0241141346
Salesrank: 371213
Weight:0.97 lbs
Published: 2001 Hamish Hamilton Ltd
Marketplace:New from £14.95:Used from £9.59
Buy from Amazon.co.uk
Amazon.ca info
Paperback 352 pages  
ISBN: 0140299866
Salesrank: 233544
Weight:0.56 lbs
Published: 2002 Penguin UK
Marketplace::Used from CDN$ 53.46
Buy from Amazon.ca

Synopsis
The history of economic genius is a tale of brilliance, egomania and borderline insanity. Since the earliest days, a cast of sometimes highly colourful individuals have pondered on the key to accumulating wealth and power. Paul Strathern has produced an erudite and witty narrative of these thinkers, together with their miraculous, and sometimes disastrous, ideas. Men like Adam Smith, Karl Marx and John Maynard Keynes were fascinating characters as well as influential thinkers. But there are also a host of lesser-known figures whose theories were as eccentric as they were - the mediaeval monk who invented game theory by studying a ball game; the escaped Scottish murderer who controlled France's finances; numerous crackpot academics; and, of course, Dr. Strangelove himself, John von Neumann, the sinister genius who applied game theory to everything from economics to nuclear strategy. Paul Strathern uncovers the lives and ideas of the great philosophers of money against the backdrop of some of history's most turbulent events: the South Sea Bubble, the French and Russian Revolutions and the Crash of 1929. On the way he provides an enriching and entertaining account of the great, the good and the downright bad in economic theories -from double-entry book-keeping to game theory. In fact, everything you ever wanted to know about economics, but were too afraid to ask.
 
A Great Introduction to Economic Thought ****
This concise book is well written and reads well. Taking the reader through a selection of the most important thinkers that the world has seen, the author also adds interest by contextualising the thoughts of the economic thinkers he studies.

The reading list at the back of the book is particularly useful as the author does seem to rely on other books quite heavily in some chapters (notably Francis Wheen's superb biography of Marx). Overall though this is exactly what it says on the tin - and all the better for it - an intriguing and informative read

 
Enjoyable insight into those who shaped economic thought *****
The book offers very interesting insights into the personalities and events that have shaped the science / psychology of economics. I recommend this book to anyone, especially those working in the financial services industry. It is both humourous and easy to read.
 
Enthralled - the most exciting business book I ever read. *****
Picked during a skim through the bookshop shelves this book was an amazing discovery, I gained a brief overview of economics and the way economic thought developed. Never studying economics before, this book enthralled me and produced real desire to significantly deepen my understanding. Throughout the whole book the presentation is revealing, engaging and humorous (though the chapter on Marx is quite direct), The personal discussion about the great thinkers maybe almost scandalous but leaves the reader needing to satisfy more detail for each character. I'm now studying avidly to ensure that this discovered gem of economics is polished to expose greater appreciation of the world I live in. My thanks to the author who made this book live for me.
 
What is Strathern's Game? *
This book is intended to illuminate various "economic ideas" by reference to the lives of their progenitors. The text directed to the life of John von Neumann is so far wide of the mark, that one should have serious doubts about the accuracy of the entire book. John von Neumann was a highly distinguished mathematician and scientist who made great contributions in a number of important fields, and does not deserve the scurrilous descriptions produced in this book. He was not a womaniser, nor was he the model for Dr Strangelove. The MANIAC was very advanced for its time, and was copied all around the world. Even von Neumann's "Hidden Variable theorem" of Quantum Mechanics is misrepresented and evidently not understood. The story about memorising pages from phone-books originates from one of his jokes: "I know every number in this phone-book, now all I have to do is remember the names that go with them!" Just how big does Strathern imagine the Budapest phone-book to be at the beginning of the twentieth century? Strathern's interpretation of the Theory of Games and the Minimax Theorem shows a remarkable ignorance of their meaning. The stories about von Neumann's sojourn in Walter Reed hospital are generally inventions and exaggerations, although it is true to say that his utterances during this time were carefully evaluated by the US government.

This book, in its treatment of John von Neumann's contributions, merely repeats the misinformation of some previously discredited works, and raises serious questions about the value of the entire book.


Tachyos.org  |  Chronon Critical Points  |  Recent Science Book Reviews